The directive creates a legal framework for conducting proportionality assessments before introducing new, or modifying existing, legislative, regulatory or administrative provisions restricting access to or pursuit of regulated. Application of the proportionality doctrine in the case law of the ecthr. The exercise of subsidiarity and proportionality within the eu is clearly linked to the competence of the eu to make law. Even a superficial analysis of the caselaw of the european courts of rights will. The first edited collection for students, this new text provides a fresh and modern guide to eu law. What lady arden meant to clarify was that it appeared that proportionality brings judges closer to the fine line between law and politics.
Proportionality and the european arrest warrant gherson. I will use these cases to throw further light on the nature of the proportionality principle and the problems it brings. Whilst the principle of proportionality indisputably plays a crucial role in the protection of fundamental rights, it is still unclear to what extent it applies to other fields in international law. Furthermore, eu law recognises overriding reasons in the public interest including the financial equilibrium of social. The principle of proportionality plays an important part in european union eu law and influenced english law through cases governed by eu law. The famous weight formula, developed by alexy in his postscript to a theory of constitutional rights oup 2002 is then introduced and. Proportionality and data protection in the case law of the. European union action and is led by the foreign and commonwealth office. How intense is the scrutiny made under the chosen test. The impact of european integration and the economic. The development of subsidiarity and proportionality after the implementation of the lisbon treaty.
English law in the case of human rights compatible with the convention or where eu law is invoked to make it conform with eu law in accordance with the uks treaty obligations. Quotes and examples from key eu legislation and academic sources are also included to help develop your understanding of eu law, while further reading suggestions for each chapter act as a springboard for further studyand assessment preparation. Under the principle of proportionality, the content and form of union action shall not exceed what. Since the uk joined the european union in 1973, judges have been required to apply the proportionality test in cases with a european dimension and increasing pressure has been placed upon the judiciary to incorporate the test into domestic administrative law. The article analyses the application of the proportionality principle in the viking and. Divided into three parts, the book presents arguments against the proportionality test, critiques the view of rights entailed by it, and proposes an alternative understanding of fundamental rights and their. The objective of the general directive is particularly important in relation to the application of the principle of proportionality under data processing law, because the outcome of a proportionality test must always reflect the objectives of the general directive. Flashcard glossary interactive flashcards containing key words and terms allow you to test your knowledge and understanding. A critical view politics masters thesis 2015 ebook 0. Subsidiarity is a principle which governs the choice of who should act, in situations where potentially more than one actor is able to act. It is well known in the administrative law of many european countries, in particular germany, having its origins in prussian law in the 19th century. The other sees proportionality as allowing for openended moral reasoning. Having first discussed the implications of the proportionality principle being a general principle of law, and what function it hasnamely to secure. The book may also be of relevance to policy makers involved in shared policy areas.
Dec 19, 2019 and in the relevant case law, but also a practical and creative focus on solutions to complex problems, with often competing policy priorities4. Proportionality a german approach by yutaka araitakahashi this article briefly discusses the nature and character of the principle of proportionality in relation to administrative discretion in german public law. The socalled austerity case law has been praised by some commentators, but criticised. This report examines two general principles of eu law, and one specific article. The coming into force of the uk human rights act 1998 31 in 2000 has incorporated the european convention on human rights 32 into domestic english law and thus proportionality now plays a. The article urges the ecj to develop a different standard.
Even a superficial analysis of the case law of the european courts of rights will. Justifications and proportionality lu research portal lunds. Office of management and budget does not impose a proportionality test, its mandate to agencies to demonstrate that their measures are costjustified is broadly similar in spirit. One sees proportionality as a doctrinal tool that optimizes rights and public interests. Lord diplock, in the gchq case, reiterated these and labeled them procedural impropriety, illegality and irrationality. Pdf the principle of proportionality in international law. The gebhard test has been used many times in later cases, sometimes with slight variations in the. Together with the principle of subsidiarity, the principle of proportionality regulates the exercise of the powers conferred by the member states to the eu see practice note, eu law essentials.
Structure of the proportionality test oxford scholarship. The eu proposal for 2 different tests of proportionality. Having first discussed the implications of the proportionality principle being a general principle of law, and what function it hasnamely to secure legitimacy for judicial decisionsthe author suggests that there are several ways in which the principle can be interpreted. The supreme court stated that proportionality as a general principle of eu law involves a consideration of two questions. This principle defined in article 5 teu in the following manner. Proportionality in international law international law. The role of proportionality in international investment. In the context of fundamental rights, such as the right to the protection of personal data, proportionality is key for any limitation on these rights. The fair balance test in the case law under the european.
Eu proportionality test for regulated professions common set of criteria. Within eu law, proportionality is a principle that mainly serves as a framework for decisions to determine whether andor to what extent rights can be limited by governmental intervention such as legislation that is motivated by public interests. Proportionality and karlsruhes ultra vires verdict. The principle of proportionality in the viking and laval cases. The concept of proportionality is used as a criterion of fairness and justice in statutory interpretation processes, especially in constitutional law, as a logical method intended to assist in discerning the correct balance between the restriction imposed by a corrective measure and the severity of the nature of the prohibited act. Proportionality is to be considered against the specific matters at cpr 44. The principle of proportionality is laid down in article 5 of the treaty on european union teu. Whilst many practitioners were somewhat disappointed by the restrictive nature of the proportionality test it nevertheless offers an important and welcome new avenue of challenge. United kingdom association of european law annual address. An eu directive would significantly facilitate the obligation for member states to comply with the proportionality principle and would guarantee that member states implement the proportionality test in an equivalent manner at all levels of regulation in order to avoid fragmentation of the single market. Proportionality lancaster eprints lancaster university. The case law will doubtless develop further in 2015 but the case of miraszewski is a useful guide to the application of the proportionality test under s. Nevertheless, the development of jurisprudence and academic theory has fleshed out a standardised scrutiny process consisting of three often. For lecturers password protected to ensure only lec turers can access these resources.
Supreme court delivers landmark decision on proportionality. The modern procedural definition of the proportionality test is relatively clear. The principle of proportionality in eu law is muni masarykova. Each chapter has been written by an expert inthe field to provide you with access to a broad range of ideas while offering a solid foundation in the.
Supreme court on eu and echr proportionality back to. The court of justice of the european union hereinafter, the cjeu has recognised that eu legislation is often required to meet several public interest objectives which may. Professor of public law, eu law, public international law and jurisprudence, university of hamburg. The lisbon treaty gave the eu the opportunity to reform its position regarding its competencies which had been described as being unprincipled as well as being unclear 2 with the system in place since the maastricht treaty. Edps guidelines on assessing the proportionality of. The lisbon treaty gave the eu the opportunity to reform its position regarding its competencies which had been described as being unprincipled as well as being unclear with. Proportionality in the united kingdom revue generale du droit. In addition, the action must be, 1987, ecr 4587, paragraph 15. Constructive dialogue between the english and scottish courts malcolm jarvis 14. In the principle of proportionality in the laws of europe ed e ellis. Proportionality is a general principle in law which covers several special concepts.
Pdf the principle of proportionality in european union law. Barristers challenged the quality assurance scheme for advocates or qasa, on eu grounds. In the eu context, it refers to the choice of whether to act at eu, national or subnational levels, with a preference for. In this article the author assesses the proportionality principle in eu law from a legal theoretical and constitutional perspective with the aim of discovering the function of the principle. It provides a comprehensive critique of the proportionality principle, and particularly of its most characteristic component, balancing. Proportionality and the rule of law cambridge core. Proportionality is a general principle in criminal law used to convey the idea that the severity of the punishment of an offender should fit the seriousness of the crime. In respect of both eu law and convention rights, the uk courts apply the principle of proportionality as a tool of interpretation.
A book of this type cannot of necessity provide an indepth account of the eu. Proportionality in german public law is an elusive concept, and its terminology in the case law has been the source of strong disagreement among legal writers. Proportionality and the european convention on human rights. There are aims which are recognised as public interest objectives under eu law including public health, as set out in article 61 of the proportionality directive. The court of justice of the european union subsidiarity and. Land hessen judgment of 9 november 2010, not yet published,1 the court of justice of the european union court of justice was called upon to balance the right. This enables judges to decide whether a measure has gone beyond what is required to attain a legitimate goal and whether its claimed benefits exceed the costs. The book also considers the extent to which a court which is dedicated to enhancing the. The principle of proportionality is commonly associated with the retributivist.
Human rights cases gain gradually ground in the european legal scene and. In the eu it legitimizes the constitutional claims of eu law in the context of a multilevel legal system. Chapter one sets out the historic development of subsidiarity and proportionality as general principles of eu law. In this article i argue against the proportionality test in human rights adjudication. This brief chapter explains the four subtests of the principle of proportionality and their role in rights reasoning. Kleiner white house report, hamilton project, both books, newest studies. Bank ecb and the court of justice of the european union cjeu had acted beyond their. View the article pdf and any associated supplements and figures for a period of 48 hours. Proportionality and the balancing of rights in the caselaw. This report examines two general principles of eu law. Whether the measure in question is suitable or appropriate to achieve the objective pursued. Why does proportionality matter for the constitution.
In the former case, a manifestly disproportionate test is usually applied, while in the latter case, a least restrictive means test lrm is normally used. A critique of proportionality by francisco urbina ssrn. European union cjeu and the european court of human rights ecthr. It explores their similarities and the differences in the mechanisms. As the content for this book is primarily doctrinal, legal and critically analytical of eu law and the court of justice, the intended audience for the book is for academics, academic libraries, undergraduate and postgraduate eu law students as supplementary reading. The concept of proportionality is used as a criterion of fairness and justice in statutory interpretation processes, especially in constitutional law, as a logical method to assist in discerning the correct balance between. The exact nature of the proportionality test that should be applied to eu and hra cases is also subject to confusion. Edited by catherine barnard and steve peers, this new eu law textbook draws together a range of perspectives from experienced academics, teachers and practitioners from a number of jurisdictions to provide a comprehensive introduction to eu law.
Therefore, in the light of daly and alconbury the current position of proportionality in domestic common law is confused. Pdf the principle of proportionality in european union. The function of the proportionality principle in eu law. The application of proportionality in the eu differs based on whether eu legal acts or legal acts of the member states are concerned. Proportionality is incorporated into the law of the united kingdom in four ways. In this regard, the principle of proportionality has become one of the cornerstones of the eu law and provided muchneeded clarification with regards the division of competences.
Compliance with the principle of proportionality is also a requirement of the justification of other national measures falling within the scope of eu law, including those which derogate from other rights protected by the treaties, such as the right to equal treatment or nondiscrimination, or fundamental rights such as the right to family life. Supreme court on eu and echr proportionality back to basics. The third proportionality sub test is that of proportionality in the narrow sense. The proportionality test in uk administrative law a new. Efpa psy and europe proportionality test for new national. To speak of human rights in the twentyfirst century is to speak of proportionality. The principle of proportionality chapter 6 general principles of. Pdf the principle of proportionality and european contract law. Proportionality as a general principle of eu law involves a consideration of two questions.
First, the doctrine of proportionality is not, of course, unique to human rights law. And all this in a case about trying to improve standards for barristers advocacy. Jun 27, 2015 it varies between echr and eu law, and the tests of eu proportionality then vary according to the nature of the eu issue in play. Proportionality test and balancing on a national and european level. It restricts authorities in the exercise of their powers by requiring them to strike a balance between the means used and the intended aim. This book explores how proportionality can offer a more structured and. Furthermore, eu law recognises overriding reasons in the public interest including the financial equilibrium of social security systems, or social policy objectives.
The court of justice of the european union subsidiarity. The criticism has largely focused on the final proportionality. The principle of proportionality is one of the general principles of eu law. This structured proportionality examination allows the court to scrutinise the substantive legality or merits of discretionary policy choices enacted. Proportionality has been received into the constitutional doctrine of courts in continental europe, the united kingdom, canada, new zealand, israel, south africa, and the united states, as well as the jurisprudence of treatybased legal systems such as the european convention on human rights. Pdf the proportionality principle and what it means in. The author argues that its rigorous application is premised on germanys special historical context and.
The role of proportionality in international investment law. The last step of the proportionality test, balancing of proportionality in its narrower sense, is analysed by means of the law of balancing. Proportionality is a general principle of international law that presupposes that an examination of a possible conflict between different rights will follow some general rational rules that have the goal of ensuring that even restricted rights will not be completely suppressed. In june 2018, the eu formally adopted the directive on a proportionality test for new regulation of professions. Proportionality is a general principle of eu law, enshrined in article 54 of the treaty on european union teu and reflected elsewhere in the eu treaties, for example in article 36 teu. The principle of proportionality requires that there be a reasonable relationship between a particular objective to be achieved and the means used to achieve that objective. Indeed, this would be a consistent interpretation with eu law, but interestingly does fully exemplify the multilevel nature of proportionality especially where sources are so varied. Within criminal law, it is used to convey the idea that the punishment of an offe. Proportionality is a legal principle that allows or requires balancing between competing values. Originating most clearly in german 19 th century administrative law, proportionality has become a standard feature of constitutional analysis. There have been statements of intention but not a full judicial ruling.
174 1452 72 535 918 25 1246 682 648 1470 892 881 1131 634 862 1697 1521 698 923 1515 1664 1451 1236 1440